Her eyes filled, and for the first time in 20 years, I saw Clara without the armor.
“Elena was always the one everyone loved,” she confessed. “Even Josh loved you boys more than he ever loved me. If you knew the truth, what was I? Nothing. Just the woman who couldn’t measure up to a dead sister.”
“So you let us believe our mother threw us away.”
I set the letter down between us.
A single tear traced the line of her jaw. Clara didn’t wipe it away.
I folded my hands over Mom’s words.
“I forgive you, Clara,” I said. “But I won’t pretend anymore. We’re not going to call. We’re not going to visit. You’ll live with what you did, and that’s enough.”
Clara nodded, her shoulders caving inward.
Grandma Ruth reached across and laid one trembling hand over her daughter’s wrist, and Clara did not pull away. She just sat there and watched us leave.